Company Directory

Steve Pfenninger is the owner and president of the agency. He is a third generation member of the firm, following his grandfather J.J. Pfenninger and father Paul F. Pfenninger. After graduation from New Castle Chrysler High School, and then Indiana University in 1974, Steve joined the agency in 1975. He received the Chartered Property and Casualty Underwriter (CPCU) designation in 1982, Chartered Life Underwriter (CLU) in 1988, Chartered Financial Consultant (ChFC) in 1990, and Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) in 1991. Steve remains active in insurance education: "I can best serve my insureds by understanding their needs and how to effectively handle those needs through risk management and insurance." While specializing in commercial insurance, Steve is also eager to help you with home, auto, group, and individual life and health insurance.

Josh Estelle is a lifelong resident of Henry County. He joined the Pfenninger Agency in June, 2000, after graduating from Wabash College in the spring. A standout athlete at New Castle Chrysler High School, Josh went on to Wabash to become the all-time career scoring leader, and the only player in Wabash history to score more than 2000 points during his four years. Not only did Josh receive All-American status as a Wabash player, he was also named academic All-American in his senior year. Josh attended Safeco Insurance Company's commercial insurance school in 2000 and received the award as top student in his class. Josh received his CIC (Certified insurance councilor) designation in 2003. He is currently working on his CPCU (Chartered Property and Casualty Underwriter) designation which is 80% completed. He is eager to help you with all of your insurance needs including home, auto, commercial, life, and health.